- ประเทศ: บราซิล
- ข้อความ 330
Mendacapote (แสดงโปรไฟล์) 22 กุมภาพันธ์ 2008, 04:07:10
About “things to hook sounds to” you are absolutely right; we need to relate those complex sounds (words and phrases) to facts, objects, images, feelings, etc. But I never said you should stop reading, watching pictures, movies, or anything else. I only prevent you from translation(or should I have said "warn you against"?), that’s all.
- ประเทศ: โปแลนด์
- ข้อความ 246
russ (แสดงโปรไฟล์) 22 กุมภาพันธ์ 2008, 07:14:16
- ประเทศ: สหรัฐอเมริกา
- ข้อความ 6
Genna_StCloud (แสดงโปรไฟล์) 23 กุมภาพันธ์ 2008, 00:12:40
I've *TRIED* to study-- Spanish, Latin, German, Russian, Classical Greek, Esperanto, ASL, and Welsh. Am I fluent? NOT, though I can still carry on simple conversations in German, Spanish and ASL, and am learning to do so in Welsh. Passive auditory comprehension, via target-language music or TV is difficult even in my 'second-best' language, though I can follow Spanish and German conversations with "got it, got it, *strange word*, got it, oh that must mean--" functional recognition. I'd call it 70% comprehension.
Memory retention isn't the only issue in learning. I have a visual *processing* disorder. It means that it measuraby and demonstrably longer than normal-to-me for my brain to take in certain kinds of information and understand what it is. I may also have an auditory processing delay, but it's unclear how much the visual issue is compounding the auditory one.
Learning style and your ability to make sense of the world around you (auditory, visual, and kinesthetic input, among others) mean that you have a unique set of strengths and weaknesses. If you repeat the same phrase a thousand times to someone without an audio or visual processing problem, it's going to stick fairly quickly, depending on the frequency of repetition and the gap between each repeition. (Short term and long term memory as you put it.) The fewer the repetitions, in general, makes someone a 'quick study' at languages or math. (A 'natural' in sports.)
What helps me, or someone with severe auditory issues, can also help someone with lesser problems. Maybe we should start a specific thread on 'visual tips', 'auditory tips' and 'immersion tips'?
Since I've got some space left--
Try *Children's Songs* on CD or MP3.- This has been easiest to obtain in Spanish and the only trick is NOT to accept 'whatever looks good'. If you can hear the music before buying, look for things that have slow, clear melodies with very little sound clutter in the same tones as the speakers' voices. One singer is better than a chorus. I was very, very grateful to a bilingual friend of mine: she helped me pick out two CDs in Spanish that were clear. I listened to them until the discs went limp.
*Record your own lists and simple descriptions.* I'm just beginning this in Esperanto, but the basic technique works for each language I've tried. Take pictures of your family, the rooms in your house, your pets, then set a timer for a short amount of time. Record yourself describing the things/people in the picture, and stop when the timer dings. Only record every tenth or fifteenth practice.