Al la enhavo

Hitler's Bad Logic

de Alkanadi, 2015-aprilo-28

Mesaĝoj: 4

Lingvo: English

Alkanadi (Montri la profilon) 2015-aprilo-28 15:58:54

This is from Mein Kampf
"As long as the Jew has not become the master of the other peoples, he must speak their languages whether he likes it or not, but as soon as they became his slaves, they would all have to learn a universal language (Esperanto, for instance!), so that by this additional means the Jews could more easily dominate them!"

Source

How does a universal language help Jews dominant people? I fail to see the logic. Don't dictators normally want to divide and conquer? Isn't it easy to control a population that is divided rather than united?

What am I missing? How does Esperanto help anyone enslave the world?

Tempodivalse (Montri la profilon) 2015-aprilo-28 16:04:27

Why would one assume that a psychopath's ramblings are supposed to make sense?

Hitler didn't like Esperanto for the same reason Stalin didn't - it was too cosmopolitan.

nornen (Montri la profilon) 2015-aprilo-28 16:06:27

Language policy has always been a tool of oppression.
If you want to destroy culturally a people, take away their language and force them to speak the occupier's language, take away their cloths and force them to wear the occupier's fashion, take away their dances and tell them that those dances are diabolic. (The latter is what e.g. Mormons are doing in Central America).

A people which lacks cultural identity will also loose its unity and its common cosmovision and goals. If you manage to destroy the identity of a people, this people won't rise up against their oppressors because they don't have anything left worth fighting for.

On a side note: Esperanto wasn't intended to replace native languages and to be forced upon people, hence the comparison of oppressive language policy to Esperanto is somewhat moot.

Maybe related.

kaŝperanto (Montri la profilon) 2015-aprilo-28 17:38:23

I agree with the others; either Hitler was deluding himself or he was knowingly creating a fallacious argument to mislead people into following his craziness. The only culture Esperanto aims to oppress is that of nationalism and ignorance.

Reen al la supro