본문으로
댓글 쓰기

Appraisal: Ivy K Reed Grammar

글쓴이: 1Guy1, 2011년 11월 26일

글: 4

언어: English

1Guy1 (프로필 보기) 2011년 11월 26일 오후 4:46:01

Hi
I've got a print copy of Ivy Kellerman Reed's 'Complete Grammar of Esperanto.' It is freely available on line (www.gutenberg.org_Kellerman)

It comes across as quite good & still very usable, my one concern is that it is old.

Has the language changed that much. Is it still relevant to Esperanto as it is now used?

Thanks
Guy

sudanglo (프로필 보기) 2011년 11월 26일 오후 11:41:10

The only point I noticed on a quick read through is that it seems to over-emphasize the compound tenses (esti + particle) which tend to be used somewhat sparingly in practice.

However you need to know of them and to be able to use them where the simple forms would be misleading.

cFlat7 (프로필 보기) 2011년 11월 27일 오전 12:43:14

It is old and has some archaic usages but I enjoyed using it. Someone in our Esperanto group, re-typeset the Gutenburg version. You can get it here:

http://esperanto-edmonton.wikidot.com/kellerman-...

The web page also includes an answer key for the first 17 lessons. Some of the archaic usages are mentioned and discussed in this answer key.

And if you are interested, we had also scanned and make available Benson's "Universala Esperanto Metodo":

http://esperanto-edmonton.wikidot.com/download:u...

sudanglo (프로필 보기) 2011년 11월 27일 오전 11:37:13

Re: The Benson Course. Ah! Those were the days - when a man could smoke a good cigar without being bothered by the health-police

다시 위로