Al la enhavo
Respondi

Kiu or Kia

de Alkanadi, 2014-aŭgusto-18

Mesaĝoj: 3

Lingvo: English

Alkanadi (Montri la profilon) 2014-aŭgusto-18 07:36:43

I read this in the course titled Jen nia IJK:

Ina: Kabe estas interesa nomo...
Kabe: Ĉu? En kiu maniero?

Shouldn't it be Kia instead of Kiu. Because he is asking in what way is his name interesting.

Thanks

tommjames (Montri la profilon) 2014-aŭgusto-18 08:28:15

Firstly, if we apply your logic it would need to be 'kiel' rather than 'kia', since the latter means what kind. However, "En kiu maniero" means the same as "kiel", so if you're going to use another correlative you would want to replace the whole expression rather than the single word.

Ina: Kabe estas interesa nomo...
Kabe: Ĉu? Kiel?

sudanglo (Montri la profilon) 2014-aŭgusto-18 09:40:37

Shouldn't it be Kia instead of Kiu. Because he is asking in what way is his name interesting.
You have a point. Both are possible, however. In this case the difference is small. The answer to en kiu maniero is going to be similar to the answer to en kia maniero.

In other cases, one form would be dominant, because the other would be a strange question.

Mia amiko ankaŭ loĝas en (nomo de urbo).

Ho, jes. En kiu strato? - nomo de la strato

Ho, jes. En kia strato? - Pardonon!!

Reen al la supro