Missatges: 3
Llengua: English
Hound_of_God (Mostra el perfil) 13 de gener de 2015 11.36.20
If I wanted to say "Read that, which was given to you", would it be "Legu tion, kion estas donita al vi" or with "kio" instead?
It has to have recieved an action to be given, yes? But if I use "esti" is it still an object?
Thank you for any help.
It has to have recieved an action to be given, yes? But if I use "esti" is it still an object?
Thank you for any help.
tommjames (Mostra el perfil) 13 de gener de 2015 12.14.24
The "kio" here functions as a relative pronoun making it the subject of "estas", and so does not take the -n ending. The correct phrase is "Legu tion, kio estis donita al vi".
kaŝperanto (Mostra el perfil) 13 de gener de 2015 15.53.08
tommjames is correct. These constructs do not have to agree in accusative endings; treat them as though they were two separate sentences with their own subjects/objects and apply the appropriate endings to the correlatives.
Also note that "was given" is "estis donita" and not "estas donita". It is a minor difference, but an important one nonetheless.
Also note that "was given" is "estis donita" and not "estas donita". It is a minor difference, but an important one nonetheless.