글: 5
언어: English
mbalicki (프로필 보기) 2015년 7월 7일 오전 11:35:33
WereVrock:Mi aĉetis tiun, kiun mi ŝatas.This one is perfectly fine and says “I bought that one, which I like”.
WereVrock:Mi aĉetis, kiun mi ŝatas.This one is also correct and synonymous to the one before. You can look at it as an ellipsis of the word “tiun” (which is obvious and omitting it doesn't cause confusion).
WereVrock:Mi aĉetis, tiun mi ŝatas.Written like that, this one is wrong. If you'd write this as “Mi aĉetis. Tiun mi ŝatas”, then it could make sense but without stronger connection between the two sentences: “I bought. — [pause] — I like that one”.
WereVrock:Mi aĉetis kiun, tiun mi ŝatas.This one is simply wrong.
Well, but I'm not an expert, so I'll be happy to hear someone more experienced.
nornen (프로필 보기) 2015년 7월 8일 오후 3:05:48
mbalicki:I agress. However it is only wrong due to the word order (in this case the missing wh-fronting). If you change the word order, it becomes grammatical:WereVrock:Mi aĉetis kiun, tiun mi ŝatas.This one is simply wrong.
Kiun mi aĉetis, tiun mi ŝatas.
I like the one I bought.
Breto (프로필 보기) 2015년 7월 8일 오후 5:35:54
nornen:It is worth noting though, that grammatically correct or not, this is now a different sentence with a different meaning.mbalicki:I agress. However it is only wrong due to the word order (in this case the missing wh-fronting). If you change the word order, it becomes grammatical:WereVrock:Mi aĉetis kiun, tiun mi ŝatas.This one is simply wrong.
Kiun mi aĉetis, tiun mi ŝatas.
I like the one I bought.