У садржају
Одговорити

"La Espero"

од orthohawk, 03. јануар 2009.

Поруке: 16

Језик: English

orthohawk (Погледати профил) 03. јануар 2009. 19.50.22

OK, call me a fiesperantisto but I. Cannot. Stand. the music that is currently used for this poem (not only does it sound idiotic and undignified to me, but the range hurts my voice). I hate it worse than I hate okra (and, lemme tell ya, that's a LOTTA hate!) I'm sorely tempted to refuse to sing the anthem with that music when I go to my first Landa Kongreso this year.

I seem to remember seeing somewhere, a different melody for it. Am I in some kind of dreamland? Or is there actually a more....dignified sounding melody for this wonderful poem, kitchy as it can be?

Miland (Погледати профил) 03. јануар 2009. 21.15.16

The best rendering of La Espero that I have heard is the last track in the 4-CD set Tiel Sonis. It was sung by a choir at the 1977 Universala Kongreso in Rekjavik. Try that one.

Karedio (Погледати профил) 03. јануар 2009. 23.23.32

There are two other melodies that have been used. You can find them here:

http://www.geocities.com/lilandr/kantoj/eismaj/EnL...

http://www.geocities.com/lilandr/kantoj/eismaj/EnL...

Miland (Погледати профил) 04. јануар 2009. 00.41.32

Karedio:http://www.geocities.com/lilandr/kantoj/eismaj/EnL...
This second one (by Motteau) is quite nice, although it does have the disadvantage of repeating the first two lines of La Espero a number of times.

I don't see it replacing the traditional tune of the himno by Menil, but it may be worth trying out as a recreational activity during Esperanto events.

qwertz (Погледати профил) 25. јануар 2009. 21.30.08

I heard that young people dislike the "la espero" hymn. Is that correct? At the La Pafklik album the track number 16 (La Espero) is stopped after 21 seconds with a New Year's Eve cracker. The track 17 is the G-Funka versio of a song called "fek al esperanto". By the beginning of this song you can hear like some ice is dropping into a cocktail glas.

For me that looks like there excists an conflict between the matured 68 hippie and the I-Pod teens generation?

cheers,

Miland (Погледати профил) 25. јануар 2009. 21.50.58

The DVD course Pasporto al la Tuta Mondo contains a large part of a very good rendering of La Espero which may well be the one from the UK in Rejkjavik. Here's a clip on Youtube (5:23-6:35) with that version.

orthohawk (Погледати профил) 25. јануар 2009. 23.05.32

Miland:The DVD course Pasporto al la Tuta Mondo contains a large part of a very good rendering of La Espero which may well be the one from the UK in Rejkjavik. Here's a clip on Youtube (5:23-6:35) with that version.
Nope. This is the one I can't stand.

Miland (Погледати профил) 25. јануар 2009. 23.37.16

orthohawk:Nope. This is the one I can't stand.
Then I suggest that you repent, for I am quite sure that it will never be changed.

Bonan nokton.

tommjames (Погледати профил) 26. јануар 2009. 14.33.43

I wouldn't say I hate the tune, but yea it definitely sounds dated and perhaps somewhat ridiculous in the way it repeats the melody over and over with each verse. And I suspect the higher notes are out the singing range of most people, I know I certainly can't hit them without croaking.

This is of course part of the dorky and old-fasioned image of Esperanto that regrettably persists through to this day. I guess back in the late 1800's or whenever it was written it was a funky peice of music but nowadays it just sounds lame. Perhaps it's time for a new tune to be composed and voted upon by the community.

As Miland says though, probably no chance of that happening.

erinja (Погледати профил) 26. јануар 2009. 15.52.28

Almost every national anthem sounds old-fashioned. Almost every national anthem sounds like an old European hymn, even if the country is not European at all. I almost think that they purposely choose national anthems to be boring.

And the US national anthem is certainly unsingable. Probably you have to be either a professional singer, or a drunk, to sing it properly, since it is a variation of an old bar tune.

So in this sense, our Esperanto anthem is pretty much the same as every country's anthem!

If we choose a more modern tune, no doubt it too will sound dated after a while. Might as well just live with what we have.

Вратите се горе