In the Land of Invented Languages
richardhall,2009年6月1日の
メッセージ: 43
言語: English
chicago1 (プロフィールを表示) 2011年1月5日 19:59:28
T0dd:chicago1:She's a true believer. At least she wasn't dressed up as Dr. Zamenhof.
As for costumes, I'll never forget the first time I attended an party of Esperantists and saw one lady wearing an evening dress in a fabric of dark green stars on a pale green background.
Todd
qwertz (プロフィールを表示) 2011年1月5日 20:38:06
ceigered:It definitly is a living language. Simply check i.e. the partoprenintoj numbers of the IJK and what efforts they took to travel to the renkontiĝon location. I'm sometimes quite a bit shocked/surprised what (money) efforts international esperantists take to join a European (in detail JES, maybe it's the same for FESTO) Esperanto renkontiĝon. Okay, there are a lot of "travel around Europe" gap-year'ers. But. Pooh. Incredible.
Esperantists often try hard to differentiate esperanto by talking about how much it is a living language, ...
At last JES I heard (surloke) that 50 participants from Ukraine went via a train(?) karavano to Germany. Hey, these are around 1,300 kilometres just for the wish of attenting a international Esperanto renkontiĝo. 1,300 of "crowded European" kilometres. In my opinion Esperanto definitly is a living language.
russ (プロフィールを表示) 2011年1月5日 22:17:10
ceigered:Everyone looks awful with a rubber forehead and pointy earsA bit of easy googling can disprove that assertion.
As for the notion that it's an "insult" to mention Esperanto along with Elvish and Klingon... that sounds like a serious chip on the shoulder, like someone feeling insulted that humans and cows and pigs are all mentioned in a book about mammals.
Whether or not it serves the cause of promoting Esperanto is a separate question, but I find it difficult to believe that the book's author intended to insult Esperanto; the intent was to discuss various significant constructed languages, since it is, after all, a book about constructed languages (as opposed to a book about promoting Esperanto, or a book about groups persecuted by the Nazis, or any of the other notions being used to argue that it's an insult...)