Contenido

It's English but not as we know it, Jim

de sudanglo, 5 de mayo de 2011

Aportes: 167

Idioma: English

Chainy (Mostrar perfil) 12 de mayo de 2011 16:00:52

henma:Hey, targanook... Stop attacking people. Nobody is talking about American International Politics (whether you agree with them or not), nor about shooting people instead of offending them... The issue is that THESE forums have rules, and one of them is to avoid offensive comments about other people/countries/races/etc.

I also noticed that you don't like English, it's a difficult language to master, lots of people are forced to learn it to get (better) jobs (or even to study some subjects, like aviation or computers science), but the language itself should not be blamed for that. And the (English/American/Australian/etc.) people in this forum is not guilty either. On the contrary, these are people who realize that we need a really international language (BTW: as somebody already said, English speaking people who become Esperantists should be doubly congratulated).

This thread is about an interesting article (though a bit biased, I would say) on "Lingua Franca" and (maybe) the future role of English in this matter.

By the way... you're all wrong... It's not Chinese, it's not English... the future is Spanish, THAT is the best language... it sounds beautiful, you know how one word should be pronounced as soon as you see it written, it has great culture and literature... and it's MY native language!!! (just joking, if you didn't notice)

Let's finish the discussion and focus on constructing a better future, not on destroying our present.

Amike,

Daniel.
Excellent post. Fully support you there.

geo63 (Mostrar perfil) 12 de mayo de 2011 17:19:59

targanook:If the Americans are such nice to Arabs then why do they shoot them? Perhaps bullets are less offending than words. And why is America so hated by the Arabs? Try to answer that questions honestly.
Hej, daj se siana stary.

What have you been smoking out there? In a moment you will demand the answer why the America dropped atomic bombs on poor Japanese people or why they started war in Vietnam, Irak and so. None of the guys here know the answer so DO NOT ASK these stupid questions. Is that clear? If you want the answers, read Wiki leaks or write to Mr. Obama.

qwertz (Mostrar perfil) 12 de mayo de 2011 17:37:35

Chainy:
qwertz:
I feel starting a sentence with the "you"-baseball-cudgel straight at the others head would put me into a high defensive position. You, you, you are this and not that, you aren't, you, you ... Take care, for someones it could give the trigger to use the F* response. Just to mention what politeness tries to supress. It's not adressed directly to you. Its just...
What?! Why are we now talking about baseball bats? And you're telling me to 'take care'?! This thread is utterly crazy.

I agree with Erinja. Ceigered and Qwertz should just content themselves with a private discussion on this. Maybe invite Taganook along, too as you both seem to have a freakishly intense desire to justify his very odd statement.
No, YOU spread turbocharged attacking atmosphere at this thread. And the sad thing is that you probably can not self-reflect your behaviour yourselves. I only did encounter such turbocharged behaviour in Italy. But Italians get relaxed after some time. YOU obviously not. Drink a red-wine, that let you cool down quite good.

Sorry for that comment.

targanook:If the Americans are such nice to Arabs then why do they shoot them? Perhaps bullets are less offending than words. And why is America so hated by the Arabs? Try to answer that questions honestly.
Please take in mind that these politics often relates to some very special government administration. Also, the U.S. has 310.955.497 inhabitants. So imagine, what politic trouble is happening behind the scene. I'm sure not everybody agrees what happened at governmental level. Also TV and Radio don't show everytime the atmosphere of all people of the U.S. Someones has really have to distinct that. In my opinion.

paulopolo (Mostrar perfil) 12 de mayo de 2011 19:11:02

This is interesting polish idiom between quotation-marks:
Hej, "daj se siana" stary.
It means: "give yourself a hay". Word by word:
Hey, give yourself a hay mate.

qwertz:Drink a red-wine
Today exceptionally beerridulo.gif

Ps.
Drink a red-wine, that let you cool down quite good.
instead of wine I would recommend this masterpiece:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=518XP8prwZo

qwertz (Mostrar perfil) 12 de mayo de 2011 19:54:15

paulopolo:This is interesting polish idiom between quotation-marks:
Hej, "daj se siana" stary.
It means: "give yourself a hay". Word by word:
Hey, give yourself a hay mate.
What is that idea behind international understood (in Esperanto)? rideto.gif

paulopolo:
qwertz:Drink a red-wine
Today exceptionally beerridulo.gif
But Pilsner, only. Please.

paulopolo:

Ps.
Drink a red-wine, that let you cool down quite good.
instead of wine I would recommend this masterpiece:
Kseniya Simonova - Sand Animation
Yes, very calming. And - (Na) zdrowie! sal.gif

paulopolo (Mostrar perfil) 12 de mayo de 2011 20:39:47

Danish pilsnerridulo.gif.

Prosit/Prostridulo.gif!

Ps. thanks for soft remark about the way how to present linkridulo.gif

Chainy (Mostrar perfil) 12 de mayo de 2011 21:21:37

qwertz:No, YOU spread turbocharged attacking atmosphere at this thread. And the sad thing is that you probably can not self-reflect your behaviour yourselves. I only did encounter such turbocharged behaviour in Italy. But Italians get relaxed after some time. YOU obviously not. Drink a red-wine, that let you cool down quite good.
qwertz, you seem to be a little confused. I'm not the one desperately and rather comically using bold capital letters. I'm sorry that I've hit such a nerve. You could do well to take some of your own advice, just make sure it's quite a few big gulps of that wine.

Take a deep breath and look at what was said in this thread. Everyone was agreed on the matter until Ceigered kicked off with his rambling comments, and then you ably supported him.

erinja (Mostrar perfil) 12 de mayo de 2011 21:28:01

Qwertz, if you want to continue to discuss this stuff, please take it to private messages with Ceigered or anyone else who is interested in your topic.

This forum is not for comments about Arabs, Italians, Poles, Americans, Australians, or any other national or ethnic group.

I'm sorry to say this but your experiences in Italy and Australia are not really related to the topic of this forum, and if you would like to talk about that further, perhaps you should go to private messages or to the Esperanto forums.

Donniedillon (Mostrar perfil) 13 de mayo de 2011 02:01:25

This thread has been seriously derailed. senkulpa.gif

Perhaps it is time for the admins to just shut it down? This thread does not represent the environment of support and respect that I have come to expect from Lernu!

Lets bring the discussion back to our shared interest in Esperanto. sal.gif

geo63 (Mostrar perfil) 13 de mayo de 2011 05:39:10

Donniedillon:This thread has been seriously derailed. senkulpa.gif

Perhaps it is time for the admins to just shut it down? This thread does not represent the environment of support and respect that I have come to expect from Lernu!

Lets bring the discussion back to our shared interest in Esperanto. sal.gif
Back to track:

English as future lingua franca is rather unlikely. It is difficult and requires at least 6 years of hard learning to become communicative. Right now more foreigners are using English than natives, but the variant used is quite different to what the English have been used to - it's Globish. So, I think:

1. If the economic dominance of the anglosphere is to weaken, English will be replaced by some other language (Chinese, Arabic, Spanish, ...your vote...).

2. International English will be not English as we know it, Jim. The same happend to Latin when the Roman Empire colapsed - what are French, Italian, Spanish - post-latin languages? Globish is the candidate.

3. Unlikely - people will get wiser and choose esperanto for their international communication. This is not to happen. The history shows us that the dominant language was always the language of some superpower. Esperanto is unsuported. I think, that our goal as esperantist should be not fina venko. Look at the aims of raumists - they are extremely wise and up to date.

Volver arriba