Al la enhavo
Respondi

Adult children

de Mustelvulpo, 2012-aprilo-25

Mesaĝoj: 14

Lingvo: English

Mustelvulpo (Montri la profilon) 2012-aprilo-25 20:56:43

In English, a person will often say "I have two children" even though the children may now be adults. Is it common in Esperanto to say "Mi havas du infanojn" even though the children have grown up? I've gotten the impression that "infano" should only be used for children of perhaps twelve years or younger and a word like "gefiloj" should be used for adult children. I'm looking for other opinions on this.

Chainy (Montri la profilon) 2012-aprilo-25 21:16:12

Mi havas du filojn = I've got two sons.
Mi havas du filinojn = I've got two daughters.
Mi havas du gefilojn = I've got two children (son and daughter).

So, you can use one of the above when talking about adult children. However, I think you can get away with using 'infanoj' if you want. Context would make it clear. Check out the two definitions of 'infano' in vortaro.net - that'll give you a clue!

Hyperboreus (Montri la profilon) 2012-aprilo-25 21:19:13

Forigite

Fenris_kcf (Montri la profilon) 2012-aprilo-25 22:34:52

I understand "infan(in)o" as some kind of mixture between "fil(in)o" and "knab(in)o". IMO it's unnecessary. But there's also a difference: "infan" is not one of the roots with male meaning, while "fil" and "knab" are.

acdibble (Montri la profilon) 2012-aprilo-26 00:48:51

Mi havas du idojn.

erinja (Montri la profilon) 2012-aprilo-26 01:16:26

idoj is usually only used to refer to the young of animals, not people.

Though "reĝido" as a synonym for "princo" (prince) is sometimes seen, and the Bible speaks of the "Israelidoj" (Children of Israel).

To hear someone refer to their children as "idoj" brings to my mind the word "offspring". It gives a strange impression. I don't see this usage very much, mostly just with beginners.

I prefer to reserve "infanoj" for actual children, and use "gefiloj" for adult children.

I don't really like the fact that in English, we have to add in extra descriptions to make it clear whether we are talking about children = someone's sons or daughters, versus children = young humans. I prefer to reserve "infano" for actual chronological children in Esperanto.

acdibble (Montri la profilon) 2012-aprilo-26 01:25:02

erinja:idoj is usually only used to refer to the young of animals, not people.
I thought so until I saw the definition in NPIV:

-id/.
I- Suf. esprimanta la ĝeneralan ideon de naskiteco, k uzata:
A. pri homoj por signifi, sen ia nuanco pri aĝo

erinja (Montri la profilon) 2012-aprilo-26 15:29:18

acdibble:
erinja:idoj is usually only used to refer to the young of animals, not people.
I thought so until I saw the definition in NPIV:

-id/.
I- Suf. esprimanta la ĝeneralan ideon de naskiteco, k uzata:
A. pri homoj por signifi, sen ia nuanco pri aĝo
As I said, usually. Regardless of what PIV says, in my years of speaking Esperanto, I don't generally hear anyone except beginners talking about their "idoj". Maybe you've heard differently or talked to different people than I have, but this has been my experience.

Idoj in reference to people, as I said, usually has something to do with a title (reĝido etc) or a very formal or scientific situation (like the Izraelidoj in the Bible).

Fenris_kcf (Montri la profilon) 2012-aprilo-26 15:45:41

acdibble:Mi havas du idojn.
Sound like you procreate by budding like a sponge ridego.gif

No offense. Just the way I'd understand this sentence.

EDIT: After looking in the vortaro, i have to revise my view. Looks like it's totally fine to use "ido" this way.

acdibble (Montri la profilon) 2012-aprilo-26 20:06:30

erinja:Idoj in reference to people, as I said, usually has something to do with a title (reĝido etc) or a very formal or scientific situation (like the Izraelidoj in the Bible).
Yes I could see why that is, but I think that "offspring" is too formal a translation for "ido", but we don't really have an equivalent informal English term. Speaking of which, the only translation "ido" has on this website, in English at least, is "Ido".

Reen al la supro