-enda doubts
Trilernisto-ისა და 10 ნოემბერი, 2007-ის მიერ
შეტყობინებები: 12
ენა: English
billpatt1942 (მომხმარებლის პროფილი) 17 ნოემბერი, 2007 20:42:49
As always, I defer to the old men who studied these things long ago. Enda was officialized in 1953 by the Akademio, and has the sense: what “devas” be done (e.g.skribati) for material or moral duty, what is continuing owing to do.
Devi can mean must, or ought. Although it connotes duty, I frequently feel that I have a duty to say duty be darned. One of the old men's examples is “martelenda fero”. For what moral reason does the iron have to be hammered? Eble oni devas skribi mallonga skribendan rakonton por klarigi tion. (Perhaps someone should write a morally-has-to-be-written story to clarify this.)
Continuing, the old men say, Among –inda, -ota and –enda is this difference, that –inda expresses value judgment, -ota destiny or intention, -enda an order. Example detruinda (merits destruction), detruota ( which, perhaps, will be destroyed), detruenda (that which one is continually obliged to destroy).
-Enda seems very closely related to the Latin verb part with a similar usage. Cicero always ended every speech he gave in the Senate with the phrase Cartago delenda est. Carthage must be destroyed. (E-o, Cartago detruenda est.) He thought that Rome had a material obligation to destroy Carthage as a rival. After two bloody wars Carthage lost and was obliterated. I don’t accept that there ever was a moral duty, there was only the material advantage of controlling the Mediterranean Sea.
Devi can mean must, or ought. Although it connotes duty, I frequently feel that I have a duty to say duty be darned. One of the old men's examples is “martelenda fero”. For what moral reason does the iron have to be hammered? Eble oni devas skribi mallonga skribendan rakonton por klarigi tion. (Perhaps someone should write a morally-has-to-be-written story to clarify this.)
Continuing, the old men say, Among –inda, -ota and –enda is this difference, that –inda expresses value judgment, -ota destiny or intention, -enda an order. Example detruinda (merits destruction), detruota ( which, perhaps, will be destroyed), detruenda (that which one is continually obliged to destroy).
-Enda seems very closely related to the Latin verb part with a similar usage. Cicero always ended every speech he gave in the Senate with the phrase Cartago delenda est. Carthage must be destroyed. (E-o, Cartago detruenda est.) He thought that Rome had a material obligation to destroy Carthage as a rival. After two bloody wars Carthage lost and was obliterated. I don’t accept that there ever was a moral duty, there was only the material advantage of controlling the Mediterranean Sea.
mnlg (მომხმარებლის პროფილი) 17 ნოემბერი, 2007 22:32:53
billpatt1942:(E-o, Cartago detruenda est.)I think in Latin it was "delenda". At least this is how it has been taught to me