目次へ
回答する

Volapuk more popular than Esperanto??

lagwagon555,2007年11月13日の

メッセージ: 10

言語: English

lagwagon555 (プロフィールを表示) 2007年11月13日 21:16:46

According to Wikipedia!

http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/List_of_Wikipedias

Volapuk has made it into the list of 100,000+ articles, compared to Esperanto's 90,000... last time I looked it was like like 5,000 articles. Some translation bot maybe?

Although look at article depth, Volapuk has 2, which is like a sentence a page. Still, its not doing Esperanto any favours. Time to me to browse through thousands of Volapuk articles I dont understand, deleting the articles with only a few words...

Matthieu (プロフィールを表示) 2007年11月13日 21:34:19

This was already asked here.

The Volapük Wikipedia has so much articles because, although very few people speak it, a bot is creating thousands of geographical stubs. Click the link “Random page” to see.

BasCostBudde (プロフィールを表示) 2007年11月13日 21:46:55

Don't bother Volapuk, translate articles you like into Esperanto.

Negative attention still is attention.

lagwagon555 (プロフィールを表示) 2007年11月13日 22:19:00

To be honest it was a joke, I wasn't really going to delete volapuk articles. I have spare time, but I dont have THAT much spare time.

It makes me wonder as well... although all Esperanto wikipedia articles look very well done, and in depth, but I wonder if any were created by bots?

mnlg (プロフィールを表示) 2007年11月13日 23:12:00

lagwagon555:It makes me wonder as well... although all Esperanto wikipedia articles look very well done, and in depth, but I wonder if any were created by bots?
Well, I initiated the Wikipedia article about Marco Polo in Esperanto (in 2004 or 2005, I can't remember), and that article at some point attained star status (much to the merit of following contributors, I am fairly sure).

So, perhaps 89,999+ were created by bots, but at least one wasn't ridulo.gif

ehanson (プロフィールを表示) 2007年11月16日 22:50:31

I too have penned a few articles, in fact I'm working on one right now.

cirko (プロフィールを表示) 2007年11月24日 20:17:19

"Today there are an estimated 20-30 Volapük speakers in the world. Volapük was largely displaced in the late 19th century by the much simpler and more easily-learned Esperanto."

20-30 speakers? there are more Esperanto speakers on this website alone. I don't think we have anything to worry about haha.

lagwagon555 (プロフィールを表示) 2007年11月25日 10:33:40

Thats true, although my worry was that people would think there was some sort of rivalry between the languages, if there were similar amount of supporters (as one might think, just glancing over wikipedia article numbers). Although I'm sure if they do three seconds of research they should find out the truth.

Joop (プロフィールを表示) 2007年12月2日 23:38:33

100,000 articles all for 30 some people? Wow.

Stefano B (プロフィールを表示) 2007年12月6日 21:23:09

I think the only real rivals Esperanto has are English and maybe Interlingua. Personally I don't like Interlingua because it's so biased toward European languages, especially Italian, Spanish, and Portuguese. Esperanto is biased toward European languages, too, but not as much.

先頭にもどる