Ir ao conteúdo

Translation advice

de RhysH, 7 de setembro de 2015

Mensagens: 34

Idioma: English

Alkanadi (Mostrar o perfil) 8 de setembro de 2015 07:16:13

RhysH:However I'm already at a bit of an obstacle, namely how to translate the word leftism, none of the dictionaries I have recognise it. So far I've come up with Maldekstraismo...
Maldekstraismo would probably only make sense to English speakers.

Maldekstraismo = an ideology that occupies itself with left sided things. Maybe, it is a movement for people who are left handed. Or, maybe it is a religious ideology that says you have to eat and do everything, as much as possible, using the left.

Left wing needs to be defined more specifically. Do you mean socialistic and/or liberal? Then you would need to come up with a term that represents this concept. I think socialismo is good unless you also want it to be about liberalism.

Just my thoughts

Miland (Mostrar o perfil) 8 de setembro de 2015 07:25:23

I would suggest maldekstremismo. You'll find a thread with the word maldekstremulo on this website. The tekstaro has maldekstremisma medio in the magazine Monato.

sudanglo (Mostrar o perfil) 8 de setembro de 2015 10:00:42

Bonegaj momentoj en la Maldekstrula Vivo.

Ĉi tie (write it as two words), but instead of ĉi tie mi estas for 'here we are', perhaps 'Jen mi alvenis' or 'Jen la konferenco'

The name of the conference on the board is a bit peculiar in English (why 'current', why twice international), but what you can't do in Esperanto is just string a whole lot of nouns together as separate words.

You wrote Internacia Komunisto Kurento Internacio Konferenco.

And Kurento is current as in electric current.

Perhaps Tutmonda Konferenco pri Nuntempa Internacia Komunismo

RhysH (Mostrar o perfil) 8 de setembro de 2015 13:37:43

Thanks for the suggestions.

sudanglo:Bonegaj momentoj en la Maldekstrula Vivo.
Doesn't that mean `Great moements in the left persons life`? If so that doesn't really fit, The name doesn't refer to a person but a group history. I probably should of given more examples of the strip, and explained it better. Sorry.

Ĉi tie (write it as two words), but instead of ĉi tie mi estas for 'here we are', perhaps 'Jen mi alvenis' or 'Jen la konferenco'
The name of the conference on the board is a bit peculiar in English (why 'current', why twice international),
Well I'm not the original author so any questions about the english should really be sent here, but in this case it makes sense in English, because its about the group, the International Communist Current (the name of the group) and this is there International Conference(the name and purpose of the venue) the joke of course being that they don't have many members. So International Communist Current, International Conference while a mouthful works as a sign.

Having looked at their about us section and the list of Esperanto words for current, I think fluo comes closest to their meaning, (something to do with spreading information and influence), unless of course fluo exclusively refers to water movement.

I guess reworking the sentence to La Internacio/tutmonda konferenco de la Internacia Komunisto fluo would be better.
Perhaps Tutmonda Konferenco pri Nuntempa* Internacia Komunismo
Thats a good sentence and I may use that in translating another strip, but I don't think it'll work for this one as that changes the meaning from the group the ICC, to international communism the ideology, so it loses the crux of the joke.

*Nuntempa refers to current, as in current events right?

RhysH (Mostrar o perfil) 8 de setembro de 2015 14:07:13

Oh, and I'd just like to say I appreciate everyones advice, so if I question something its merely because I don't fully understand it. And even if I don't use a suggestion it has helped me learn more about Esperanto so don't hesitate to suggest more words and phrases.

Alkanadi (Mostrar o perfil) 8 de setembro de 2015 14:11:15

RhysH:
sudanglo:Bonegaj momentoj en la Maldekstrula Vivo.
Doesn't that mean `Great moements in the left persons life
I could be wrong but I think if you say la maldekstrula then it is plural. Just like in English we used say things like "the country is dirty due to the street rat." There is more than one rat but using "the" suggests a class of rats.

Arabic also has this mechanism. I assume most languages have it as well.

erinja (Mostrar o perfil) 8 de setembro de 2015 15:50:07

When referring to "left" and "right" politics I usually use -em- with the root.

Li estas dekstrema/maldekstrema
Mi estas desktremulo/maldekstremulo

RhysH (Mostrar o perfil) 8 de setembro de 2015 16:03:28

Alkanadi:
RhysH:
sudanglo:Bonegaj momentoj en la Maldekstrula Vivo.
Doesn't that mean `Great moements in the left persons life
I could be wrong but I think if you say la maldekstrula then it is plural. Just like in English we used say things like "the country is dirty due to the street rat." There is more than one rat but using "the" suggests a class of rats.

Arabic also has this mechanism. I assume most languages have it as well.
Single or plural isn't really the issue,its the person part of it. There is a difference between an idea or label and a group to which that label applies. A komunisto is a Communist, komunistoj is a group of communists, Komunismo is the ideology they represent. Here we have Leftist, leftists and leftism.

sudanglo (Mostrar o perfil) 9 de setembro de 2015 11:00:53

International Communist Current still seems to me like an odd name for an organisation, but assuming that current here means like the current in a river, then possible translations preserving the image are tajdo, fluo, fluso, and even kurento.

However, a slightly different image might sound better, and that is 'ondo' (wave).

There is a well known magazine in Esperantujo called La Ondo de Esperanto. A definition in PIV supports this figurative use - 4.(f) provizora intensiĝo de ia sento, influo, fenomeno.

Also from the Tekstaro: Malfeliĉe — aŭ ĉu feliĉe? — ne daŭris longe ĝis mi sentis saman naŭzon pri la politika ondo!

So Tutmonda Konferenco de la Internacia Komunista Ondo.

As regards 'lefties', in modern usage, maldekstrulo is well supported (also dekstrulo for someone on the right). Historically though the term has been used for someone who is left-handed. PIV gives both meanings.

filmo70 (Mostrar o perfil) 9 de setembro de 2015 13:34:47

erinja:When referring to "left" and "right" politics I usually use -em- with the root.

Li estas dekstrema/maldekstrema
Mi estas desktremulo/maldekstremulo
Can I call myself a mezemulo? I certainly don't fit into either side. Or maybe I'm just a dekstremetulo, a little to the right overall.

De volta à parte superior