More on prepositions
by jawq81, January 16, 2009
Messages: 3
Language: English
jawq81 (User's profile) January 16, 2009, 2:13:28 PM
Oni tenas la kuleron en la dekstra mano. = One holds the spoon in the right hand.
Oni tenas la kuleron per la dekstra mano. = One holds the spoon with/by means of the right hand.
Both prepositions fit in the above sentence but they are different prepositions with different meanings. Just as a careful user would differentiate between 'kun' and 'per', so is 'en' a distinctively different word.
Also, these old courses, developed a hundred or more years ago, seem to use 'oni' much more than we use it today. Has the preference for 'oni' changed over time? I hope so. Comments?
tommjames (User's profile) January 16, 2009, 3:21:28 PM
For example if I simply wanted to stress the means by which he held the spoon and little more, I'd say per. If I wanted to say something about the general way he was holding it, I'd use the "en" form as it creates a kind of image in the mind of the person's hand with a spoon in it. "Per" by itself might not be adequate for that kind of expression.
Rogir (User's profile) January 16, 2009, 4:08:29 PM