Is there anything wrong?
de zjboon, 19 juillet 2009
Messages : 14
Langue: English
jchthys (Voir le profil) 21 juillet 2009 00:05:42
Miland:One suggestion:That seems to go against the original (Chinese) form of poetry. I think lines 1, 2, 4 and 5 need to begin with repeated words.
Lovely, lovely is your face
I've been lonely, lonely.
Will we remain strangers?
Lovely, lovely is your voice
That goes round and round in my ears
Do you still not remember?
ceigered (Voir le profil) 21 juillet 2009 13:51:26
jchthys:Well I wasn't trying to imply that the spelling should be changed, I too think the word should be spelt out in full, but in speech it can be shortened easilyceigered:Additionally, lingering can be made to match the pace in speech with lovely and lonely by further reducing the middle 'e', so it sounds like 'ling'ring' (which is ok in English poetry).It’s just a matter of preference, but I’d still spell the word out in full.
That way they are all two syllables
'love-ly'
'lone-ly'
'ling-gring'
zjboon (Voir le profil) 21 juillet 2009 13:54:54
ceigered:Well I wasn't trying to imply that the spelling should be changed, I too think the word should be spelt out in full, but in speech it can be shortened easilyI do agree, I am very grateful to you!
Miland (Voir le profil) 21 juillet 2009 15:58:07
jchthys:English is not Chinese, and attempting to preserve every aspect of form may result in the spirit being conveyed less effectively. But I would like to have zjboon's opinion on my attempt.Miland:One suggestion:That seems to go against the original (Chinese) form of poetry. I think lines 1, 2.. need to begin with repeated words.
Lovely, lovely is your face
I've been lonely, lonely..