K vsebini
Odgovori

Standalone ĉi?

od Durandal1717, 23. marec 2010

Sporočila: 10

Jezik: English

Durandal1717 (Prikaži profil) 23. marec 2010 01:06:31

I was wondering, since I don't think I've seen any examples on it, if ĉi can be used by itself to denote proximity of the nearest noun.

Such as saying 'ĉi libro' for 'this book', instead of the frankly redundant 'ĉi tiu libro', the correlative of which I would only think to use when referring to a book already mentioned. I don't think it could be easily confused with 'ĉi-', which when not subsumed into a correlative always retains its hyphen.

erinja (Prikaži profil) 23. marec 2010 02:46:51

You can definitely say "ĉi libro", no problem at all with that.

marcuscf (Prikaži profil) 23. marec 2010 03:17:00

If you say "ĉi libro", I feel something is missing, but I never heard anybody say it's incorrect.

sjheiss (Prikaži profil) 23. marec 2010 05:58:22

marcuscf:If you say "ĉi libro", I feel something is missing, but I never heard anybody say it's incorrect.
Yeah, it does seem like something is missing. Without the "tiu", it makes it seem like it has something to do with "ĉi-" than with "ti-" in the correlatives.

darkweasel (Prikaži profil) 23. marec 2010 06:24:42

This is a correct form (according to PMEG) that even I sometimes use, but I wouldn't recommend to use it in formal writing. Simplaj samsignifaj vortoj marks it as a bad form.

Durandal1717 (Prikaži profil) 23. marec 2010 07:27:27

sjheiss:
marcuscf:If you say "ĉi libro", I feel something is missing, but I never heard anybody say it's incorrect.
Yeah, it does seem like something is missing. Without the "tiu", it makes it seem like it has something to do with "ĉi-" than with "ti-" in the correlatives.
I thought this myself, until I realized it's only used in words like ĉi-matene. The only real confusing situation I could conjecture is something like "ĉi ĉio", I guess in response to a question like "kio ĉio" or something.

erinja (Prikaži profil) 23. marec 2010 16:05:04

I use "ĉi ĉio" as well, no problem. But it's not a response to "kio ĉio" (which doesn't make sense to my ear)

Imagine the following situation:
You come home, where your kids have been alone. The house is a complete mess, and it looks like a hurricane came through.

You say to your kids:
"Ho ve, kio estas ĉi ĉio???"

("Oh no, what is all of this?")

I have no kids. But I do use it to say, for example "all of this isn't important" (ĉi ĉio ne gravas).

Any case where you might want to say "all of this" or "all of this stuff", "ĉi ĉio" could be suitable.

ceigered (Prikaži profil) 24. marec 2010 05:06:00

"Ho, kio estas cxi cxio?"

That's more or less like saying "What is everything here?!", right? In which case I think such a usage of cxi makes sense (I think I might use "cxi" a bit more now, cheers Erinja for those examples lango.gif)

Roberto12 (Prikaži profil) 24. marec 2010 09:23:34

I would never modify a noun with ĉi - but that's just me.

Miland (Prikaži profil) 24. marec 2010 20:53:11

Ĉi by itself according to PMEG is a popular use, effectively a short form for ĉi tiu(j) or occasionally ĉi tie. But if there's any risk of misunderstanding, I suggest that you use the full forms.

Nazaj na začetek