Kwa maudhui
Kujibu

Naming Esperanto communities

ya Leke, 27 Machi 2015

Ujumbe: 6

Lugha: English

Leke (Wasifu wa mtumiaji) 27 Machi 2015 5:17:30 alasiri

Hi, what's the correct way to name a community in Esperanto?

For example, let's say an Esperanto gamer community, or an Esperanto enthusiast community. Would it be...

Esperanto ludanto komunumo.
Esperanta ludanta komunumo.

or something completely different?

Thanks.

tommjames (Wasifu wa mtumiaji) 27 Machi 2015 5:25:51 alasiri

The first sentence is definitly wrong as a noun cannot modify another noun in Esperanto. The second one is probably worth avoiding as use of the active participle suggests the community is playing, not just that playing is something they do.

I would go for any of the following:

Esperanta komunumo pri ludado
Esperanta priluda komunumo
Esperanta lud-komunumo

kaŝperanto (Wasifu wa mtumiaji) 27 Machi 2015 6:48:35 alasiri

This is one area I miss English's "just keep adding words, who cares what they are" attitude.

ba200ka (Wasifu wa mtumiaji) 27 Machi 2015 10:38:42 alasiri

You can still do the English way, like this

Esperanto-ludanto-komunumo

But they have to be a single word.
Still, @tommjames's is way better, because that word above sounds like you are playing esperanto

altindiefanboy (Wasifu wa mtumiaji) 6 Aprili 2015 7:48:43 alasiri

It's already been mentioned that you nouns in Esperanto can't modify other nouns, aside from compound words like Esperanto-ludanto-komunumo.

I would name them with "Esperanto" as an adjective, and the community being "of gamers".

ex.
Esperanta Komunumo de Ludantoj (Esperanto Community of Gamers)
or
Komunumo de Esperantaj Ludantoj

There's a slight difference in meaning between the two, but that's how I would do it, probably leaning towards the first example.

lagtendisto (Wasifu wa mtumiaji) 11 Aprili 2015 12:16:20 alasiri

tommjames:Esperanta lud-komunumo
Maybe everybody knowing Esperanto music could understand 'Espo lud-komunumo', too.

Espo Despo

Kurudi juu