Al contingut
Respondre

We ought to stop talking about this...

de Roberto12, 18 de desembre de 2010

Missatges: 36

Llengua: English

sudanglo (Mostra el perfil) 19 de desembre de 2010 12.17.40

Robert, I don't think ought is a diminutive of must. Rather the distinction lies in where the devo comes from.

When I use 'must' I am insisting on things from my point of view. When I use 'ought' (or have to) I am externalising the devo.

It is strange to say I must go but I won't. (this is self-contradictory)

Quite natural though to say I ought to go but I have decided not to.

And whilst 'have to' carries the idea of externally imposed necessity, 'ought' is more linked to the idea of moral obligation or debt and is something which you could ignore.

I think 'devus' will suffice in many cases for 'ought'.

sudanglo (Mostra el perfil) 19 de desembre de 2010 12.31.04

Here's a Zamehofa example for your consideration.

"Mi devus forlasi vin en via malfeliĉo,” diris la vulpo, “sed mi kompatas vin kaj ankoraŭ unu fojon mi vin savos.

Miland (Mostra el perfil) 19 de desembre de 2010 13.03.47

sudanglo:Here's a Zamehofa example..
What's the source?

Roberto12 (Mostra el perfil) 19 de desembre de 2010 13.24.19

I'm not convinced.

sudanglo (Mostra el perfil) 19 de desembre de 2010 13.27.02

One of the Grimm fabeloj, Miland. Serĉu Tekstaron.

sudanglo (Mostra el perfil) 19 de desembre de 2010 13.29.12

Fair enough Robert. If you are not convinced let's hear your counter arguments.

Miland (Mostra el perfil) 19 de desembre de 2010 14.04.53

sudanglo:One of the Grimm fabeloj, Miland. Serĉu Tekstaron.
Dankon, in that context devus appears to be used like "should". I came across one or two in the FK as well.

Roberto12 (Mostra el perfil) 19 de desembre de 2010 14.22.08

sudanglo:Fair enough Robert. If you are not convinced let's hear your counter arguments.
Simply that whereas "ought" generally concerns moral obligations (of variable force), "must" also covers them. The concepts overlap a lot, and I think the diminutive relationship works.

Chainy (Mostra el perfil) 19 de desembre de 2010 14.26.08

Roberto12:... and I think the diminutive relationship works.
I reckon you'll have a hard time trying to find anyone else using any forms of 'dev/et/i'.

Roberto12 (Mostra el perfil) 19 de desembre de 2010 14.49.00

Chainy:
Roberto12:... and I think the diminutive relationship works.
I reckon you'll have a hard time trying to find anyone else using any forms of 'dev/et/i'.
I mean that it works logically; I wasn't talking about Esperanto usage in particular.

Tornar a dalt