Missatges: 13
Llengua: English
erinja (Mostra el perfil) 4 d’octubre de 2007 13.28.24
Write in any language in this forum, but since it is the English forum, please include an English translation! We have many beginners here.
jpsparenberg:
In French there is a difference between "it's a problem" and "there is a problem".
"it's a problem" (fra : c'est un problème) means that the listener already knows which problem is being discussed. He is not waiting for additional information about that problem. So I think the translation will be : "tio estas problemo".
But "there's a problem" (fra : il y a un problème) implies another explanation. So the translation : "estas problemo" or "ni havas problemon" means that it's understood that you'll explain to the listener what the problem is.
Amike
Jean-Pol
jpsparenberg (Mostra el perfil) 4 d’octubre de 2007 20.40.23
erinja:Write in any language in this forum, but since it is the English forum, please include an English translation! We have many beginners here.I am awfully sorry. Since it's the first time I write something in this forum, I was not aware that English was mandatory. Anyway, thank you for your remark and your transalation.
jpsparenberg:
In French there is a difference between "it's a problem" and "there is a problem".
"it's a problem" (fra : c'est un problème) means that the listener already knows which problem is being discussed. He is not waiting for additional information about that problem. So I think the translation will be : "tio estas problemo".
But "there's a problem" (fra : il y a un problème) implies another explanation. So the translation : "estas problemo" or "ni havas problemon" means that it's understood that you'll explain to the listener what the problem is.
Amike
Jean-Pol
erinja (Mostra el perfil) 5 d’octubre de 2007 1.50.35
It's not exactly "mandatory" - it's just a way to be polite to the beginners. Presumably they are here because they don't yet feel comfortable enough in Esperanto to participate fully in the Esperanto forums. Perhaps they want to ask questions and understand the answers - this is the place where they can do that in a language they understand (as are all of the 'national language' forums)