Messages: 15
Language: English
Vilinilo (User's profile) May 31, 2013, 11:40:53 PM
Kirilo81:Thanks for the tip. But even though there's such a rule, it's still used before a vowell in the name of the letter itself, ŭo. I never understood why purposely limiting the usage of ŭ, I can easily pronounce ŭa, ŭe, ŭi, ŭo and even ŭu. Could it be a linguistic prejudice from Mr. Zamenhof?
There is no such ban in the Fundamento, just a rule to use ŭ after vowels only.
marcuscf (User's profile) June 1, 2013, 3:44:14 AM
etala (User's profile) June 1, 2013, 6:27:19 AM
Vilinilo:I just chalked it up to the tendency of two influential groups in the beginning of Esperanto, Russians and Germans, to avoid the sound of "ŭ" at the beginning of a syllable.Kirilo81:Thanks for the tip. But even though there's such a rule, it's still used before a vowell in the name of the letter itself, ŭo. I never understood why purposely limiting the usage of ŭ, I can easily pronounce ŭa, ŭe, ŭi, ŭo and even ŭu. Could it be a linguistic prejudice from Mr. Zamenhof?
There is no such ban in the Fundamento, just a rule to use ŭ after vowels only.
Vilinilo (User's profile) June 1, 2013, 5:36:07 PM
etala:On the other hand, to me (and I believe that values for other speakers of latin languages as well) it's a lot easier to say "akŭo" than "akvo".
I just chalked it up to the tendency of two influential groups in the beginning of Esperanto, Russians and Germans, to avoid the sound of "ŭ" at the beginning of a syllable.
jchthys (User's profile) June 4, 2013, 3:27:05 PM
Vilinilo:…meaning it would be all the worse to introduce minimal pairs with v/ŭ.etala:On the other hand, to me (and I believe that values for other speakers of latin languages as well) it's a lot easier to say "akŭo" than "akvo".
I just chalked it up to the tendency of two influential groups in the beginning of Esperanto, Russians and Germans, to avoid the sound of "ŭ" at the beginning of a syllable.