Til innholdet

Which preposition for 'kutimi'

fra ernie13,2012 2 25

Meldinger: 14

Språk: English

Hyperboreus (Å vise profilen) 2012 2 25 14:44:15

Forigite

sudanglo (Å vise profilen) 2012 2 25 17:59:37

For example: "This smells like fish." "Das riecht nach Fisch." "Eso huele a pescado." Is in Eo simply and plainly: "Tio odoras fiŝon."
Although this usage is supported by citations in NPIV, I personally would say Tio odoras je fiŝo, or odoras kiel fiŝo

I'm not convinced that 'like' in 'this smells like fish' is a preposition. This seems to me more like Tio odoras kiel fiŝo (odoras).

In English, I think many speakers would distinguish between this smells like fish (it could be fish) and this smells of fish (has a fishy smell, but it is not fish).

In Esperanto the existential import is different in.

1. Tio odoras kiel fiŝo
2. Tio odoras samkiel fiŝo.

Hyperboreus (Å vise profilen) 2012 2 25 18:27:53

Forigite

pdenisowski (Å vise profilen) 2012 2 26 05:21:10

Hyperboreus:For example:
"This smells like fish."
"Das riecht nach Fisch."
"Eso huele a pescado."

Is in Eo simply and plainly:
"Tio odoras fiŝon."
I would probably just have said "Tio havas fiŝodoron." rideto.gif

Amike,
Paul

Tibake til toppen