Mesaĝoj: 18
Lingvo: English
Simioenlaurbo (Montri la profilon) 2011-septembro-07 03:20:39
Also while I'm at it, how does one say "to get along with" as in "Do you get along with your roommate?" It's not in Wells, the Lernu dictionary or Reta Vortaro. I know there are other ways to describe the situation - "Ni ĉiam kverelas/malpaciĝas" or whatever - but I was just wondering if there was something closer to English's "to get along with" or Spanish's "llevarse bien con."
Thanks in advance!
darkweasel (Montri la profilon) 2011-septembro-07 05:33:31
Simioenlaurbo:This is a question I've had before, but I haven't come across an answer, so I'll pose it here: for words than begin with "sin," like "sinĝena," would the "sin" become "min"/"vin"/"nin" when not referring to a third-person subject, e.g. "Mi estas minĝena" or would it stay simply "Mi estas sinĝena."?It stays mi estas sinĝena.
mountainash (Montri la profilon) 2011-septembro-07 08:39:59
Simioenlaurbo:Also while I'm at it, how does one say "to get along with" as in "Do you get along with your roommate?"Peter Benson's dictionary suggests that:
"Get along (be compatible) - akordiĝi, harmoniiĝi."
So, maybe...
"Ĉu vi harmoniiĝas kun via samĉambrano?"
sudanglo (Montri la profilon) 2011-septembro-07 10:02:26
ceigered (Montri la profilon) 2011-septembro-07 15:55:14
But yeah, you use "sinĝeni" since it's just easier than using "minĝeni", only one "form" vs. 5 or so.
Why we don't say "Mi sentas sin bone", I can't say. I wonder if we can say "Mi sinsentas bone"?
darkweasel (Montri la profilon) 2011-septembro-07 16:18:05
ceigered:Uhm, no. You cannot say *sinĝeni, *minĝeni, *sinsenti. See: PMEG: Aliaj afiksecaj vortetoj: sin.
But yeah, you use "sinĝeni" since it's just easier than using "minĝeni", only one "form" vs. 5 or so.
Why we don't say "Mi sentas sin bone", I can't say. I wonder if we can say "Mi sinsentas bone"?
tommjames (Montri la profilon) 2011-septembro-07 19:07:01
ceigered:Why we don't say "Mi sentas sin bone", I can't say.It's quite simple: "Si" is a third person pronoun, and in your phrase "Mi" is first person.
Simioenlaurbo (Montri la profilon) 2011-septembro-08 00:31:17
mountainash:Peter Benson's dictionary suggests that:I like these actually. Cheers
"Get along (be compatible) - akordiĝi, harmoniiĝi."
So, maybe...
"Ĉu vi harmoniiĝas kun via samĉambrano?"
ceigered:In an effort to curb evil, I suggest we replace "sin" at the start of any words with "rajĉisnis".And here I thought it should be "virĉu."
sudanglo:Without giving it a great deal of thought, I think I would have translated 'Do you get on well with your roommate?' as 'Ĉu vi bone rilatas kun/al via samĉambrano?'.This sounds good too. Thanks!
ceigered (Montri la profilon) 2011-septembro-08 02:39:53
darkweasel:Uhm, no. You cannot say *sinĝeni, *minĝeni, *sinsenti. See: PMEG: Aliaj afiksecaj vortetoj: sin.EDIT: I replied, but was confused, so nevermind.
New message now that I know what the topic is:
Surely there's no explicit rule against "minsenti" or anything like that existing, yeah? I mean, the verb would be stupid and mean "feel me", and it's also redundant and just making things complicated, but it's not like it's breaking some sort of fundamental rule that makes it entirely unintelligible? (but bad style in any normal situation)
darkweasel (Montri la profilon) 2011-septembro-08 05:18:30
ceigered:Well, at least PMEG says that it breaks even two different rules, see my link. Of course you’re allowed not to follow PMEG.
Surely there's no explicit rule against "minsenti" or anything like that existing, yeah? I mean, the verb would be stupid and mean "feel me", and it's also redundant and just making things complicated, but it's not like it's breaking some sort of fundamental rule that makes it entirely unintelligible? (but bad style in any normal situation)