Al la enhavo

Demandi vs Peti

de byronarnold, 2008-aŭgusto-18

Mesaĝoj: 7

Lingvo: English

byronarnold (Montri la profilon) 2008-aŭgusto-18 19:53:35

What is the difference between these two verbs? How can I tell when one is appropriate over the other? Any help woud be much appreciated.

Dankon!

Matthieu (Montri la profilon) 2008-aŭgusto-18 20:09:40

If I understood correclty:
[LISTO]
demandi: to ask a question;
peti: to ask to obtain something.[/list]It's like preguntar and pedir in Spanish.

byronarnold (Montri la profilon) 2008-aŭgusto-18 20:17:34

Mutusen:If I understood correclty:
[LISTO]
demandi: to ask a question;
peti: to ask to obtain something.[/list]
Okay, I understand.

Mutusen:It's like preguntar and pedir in Spanish.
Yeah... I don't know much Spanish, so that analogy didn't help. But thanks for the effort. ridego.gif

catcourps (Montri la profilon) 2008-aŭgusto-20 14:44:37

Mutusen:If I understood correclty:
[LISTO]
demandi: to ask a question;
peti: to ask to obtain something.[/list]It's like preguntar and pedir in Spanish.
I speak spanish and have NEVER made that connection. I feel so stupid! That helps a lot. Thanks!

werechick (Montri la profilon) 2008-aŭgusto-31 04:03:31

The difference between demandi and peti esperante was the only reason why I understood that German, likewise, has seperate words.

EL_NEBULOSO (Montri la profilon) 2008-aŭgusto-31 09:20:32

Yes,

"fragen" and "bitten/erbitten" are two completely different things, hence it sounds strange to us when e.g. in French they use the same word (demander) for these separate things.

On the other hand, there are several other words to express the strength of asking for something in all the languages I am familiar with.

Fortunately, there are also these two different words for the basic fragen/bitten in Esperanto...

Gerald

Timtim (Montri la profilon) 2008-septembro-03 13:33:41

Mutusen:[LISTO]peti: to ask to obtain something.[/list]
Think of those times in English when you could use request or even petition to replace ask. These are occasions when peti is appropriate in eo.

Reen al la supro