K vsebini
Odgovori

What would have been, if...

od Hyperboreus, 26. avgust 2012

Sporočila: 20

Jezik: English

Hyperboreus (Prikaži profil) 26. avgust 2012 17:35:33

Forigite

Hyperboreus (Prikaži profil) 26. avgust 2012 17:36:06

Forigite

Vestitor (Prikaži profil) 26. avgust 2012 17:57:32

Hyperboreus:Their argumentation was: If you say “He sees me.” and “I see him.” then why don’t you say “Him runs.” and “Me runs.”, which would be only logical.
Why would it be logical? 'He sees me' and 'He runs' makes perfect alignment sense (to me), as would I see him' and 'I run'...rather than the other suggested logical inferences. The question is genuine because I'm not a linguist and I would appreciate the explanation.

Hyperboreus (Prikaži profil) 26. avgust 2012 18:06:02

Forigite

razlem (Prikaži profil) 26. avgust 2012 18:07:49

Oh lawd. Ergative case. But it looks and sounds very interesting ridulo.gif

Hyperboreus (Prikaži profil) 26. avgust 2012 18:10:28

Forigite

EldanarLambetur (Prikaži profil) 26. avgust 2012 18:34:30

Somehow, I've never looked into "absolutive" and "ergative"! Thanks for bringing them to my attention with a simple example! Looks interesting!

I shall take a peek at this Mayan Esperanto ridego.gif

Vestitor (Prikaži profil) 26. avgust 2012 18:35:10

I think I see now. So this explains similar structures in languages like Caribbean creoles and other pidgin Englishes? Like Sranan Tongo in Suriname where people say 'Mi go' (I go/am going)instead of I am going. Is that the same principle or different?

Hyperboreus (Prikaži profil) 26. avgust 2012 18:42:23

Forigite

Hyperboreus (Prikaži profil) 26. avgust 2012 18:52:43

Forigite

Nazaj na začetek